In The News
Less pain with new technique. Stem cells implanted in spine can join vertebrae that used to require metal and grafts
Modesto, CA - At a key point in the surgery, Dr. Alexander
Davis, used forceps to hold up a small, saturated crimson pad. The
rectangular pad oozed with bone marrow that had been taken from Georgia
Ford's body and put through a filter to concentrate stem cells.
"That really looks good," said the veteran surgeon,
who was doing this particular type of spinal fusion operation for only the
second time.
He then placed the pad into a large incision in Ford's
back and packed it against one side of her spine. Later, he implanted a
second pad on the other side.
The implanted cells are busy growing bone and, within
three to six months, are expected to close the gap between two segments of
Ford's spine, thus stabilizing her lower back.
There is nothing new about spinal fusion operations -
Davis has done thousands in fifteen years as a surgeon, mostly in Modesto.
But two weeks ago, he began using stem cells to create
bone grafts involved in the surgery. And the technique should reduce pain to
patients such as Ford, a 69-year-old Modesto woman who underwent the surgery
Monday morning.
"We are always striving for ways to make the patient
more comfortable and have less pain as a result of the procedures," said
Davis, who performed the operation at Memorial Medical Center and did a
second one in the afternoon.
If results are good, he said, he plans to regularly
use stem cells in the spinal operations.
Scientists believe that stem cells hold great promise
for treating muscular dystrophy, diabetes, heart disease, spinal cord
injuries and damaged organs.
These cells are present in the earliest stages of
human life and are different in that they don't perform specific functions.
Given the proper stimulus in nature or in the
laboratory, stem cells give rise to specialized cells that make up the
heart, lung, skin and other tissues.
The research is controversial because human embryos
are deemed the best source for these powerful cells. Other sources include
bone marrow, blood or skin of children and adults, but experts say these
cells can generate limited types of tissue.
Two years ago, Johnson & Johnson started testing a
stem-cell filtering device for use in bone grafts. In recent months, the
company has made it available to a few surgeons across the country,
including Davis. The device has Food and Drug Administration approval
and is set for widescale release this week.
Many people suffer back pain when discs, or the soft,
cushiony parts of their spines, wear out and create pressure on adjacent
nerves.
The standard repair involves clearing out the disc
material and fusing two spinal segments with metal plates, screws and a bone
graft.
To prepare the graft, doctors have to cut through
skin and muscle tissue to dig bone out of the patient's pelvis.
"Even though the former procedure works well, it
causes pain for the patient," said Dave Urbanz, product manager for DePuy
AcroMed, a Johnson & Johnson company that developed the filter.
"After the surgery, the patient's hip may hurt worse
than his back does, he said.
Davis said he has always looked for ways to make bone
harvesting less painful, so he was interested in the new technique.
"Now that I can definitely get the stem cells out
without digging into the pelvis, I will be using this procedure regularly,"
Davis said.
Ford had the standard surgery done a year ago and then
suffered a fall, loosening the screws and plates of the first surgery and
cracking a vertebrae.
During the four-hour operation Monday, Davis stuck
a needle into the woman's pelvis to harvest marrow. He then squeezed the
fluid into a cartridge holding a Healos pad, where the biotech magic
takes place.
The pads are coated with substances to draw the
stem cells from the marrow and stimulate them to create bone. When applied
to the spinal column, the cells will bond with the existing bones.
Because of her age and problems with osteoporosis,
Davis installed an electronic device in Ford's back to stimulate the graft.
Ford was expected to spend five days in the hospital
and then two weeks in a skilled nursing facility. Davis said she will be
scheduled for X-rays every four weeks, to make sure the fusion is taking
hold.
The need to repair the previous fusion stretched
the time of Ford's surgery. About 2 hours, 45 minutes is normal for the
stem-cell operation, same as a standard fusion.
Hospitals are usually reimbursed $11,000 for fusion
surgeries, Johnson & Johnson officials said. The filtering equipment costs
$700, but it's a wash, because one less incision is made, they said.
The normal hospital recovery time is shorter, one to three days, which
should appeal to insurance companies, the product makers said.
Mike Cully, spokesman for Kaiser Permanente, which
formerly had a contract with Memorial, said the health management
organization is open to covering new procedures grounded in good science.
"If there are clinical trials to support it and a
physician feels it is right for the patient, that is what we are going to
go with," he said.
Matt Carrillo, a specialist for DePuy AcroMed,
said stem cells also can help mend broken bones that have not healed
properly.
There is also hope some day of allowing paralyzed
people to walk again, by modifying stem cells to match the patients'
genes and then injecting the cells into their injured spinal cords to
regrow nerve tissue.
Broader applications may depend, however, on
resolving ethical debates over stem cells derived from human embryos.
Opponents charge that the research destroys human
life; proponents say the embryos that otherwise would be destroyed are
received from in vitro fertilization clinics with the donors' consent.
May 8, 2003. Ken Carlson, The Modesto Bee, p. B-1,5.
BACK
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
Alexander A. Davis, M.D.
1401 Spanos Court
Suite 122
Modesto, CA 95355
Phone: (209) 525-3888
Fax: (209) 525-3891
|
 |
|
|